With over 40 years in the roofing and gutter business, I’ve seen every type of gutter guard imaginable — from the cheapest to the outrageously pricey. Yet, I have never seen one that is 100% effective.
Why?
Small debris will find a way through any gutter guard eventually, leading to clogged gutters.
The Hidden Problem with Gutter Guards
Many modern gutter guards are screwed into the home or gutter system, which makes them nearly impossible to remove. So, when a clog finally happens, cleaning out those gutters can turn into a professional project that takes an entire day—or longer if you’re a DIYer.
Our Best Advice: Regular Gutter Cleaning
We recommend hiring a gutter cleaning company at least twice a year to keep your gutters clear and functioning. Think of it like flossing your teeth—nobody loves it, but there’s really no substitute if you want to avoid bigger problems down the road.
Gutter Guard Limitations to Keep in Mind:
-
Small debris like pine needles or roof grit can still sneak through many guards.
-
Some designs require regular cleaning to remain effective.
-
Improper installation can cause overflowing, water damage, or even void warranties.
-
They are not maintenance-free — guards reduce cleaning frequency but don’t eliminate it.
🛠️ Types of Gutter Guards — Pros and Cons
| Type | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Mesh Screens | Blocks small debris, highly effective | Can clog if not maintained |
| Reverse Curve/Surface Tension | Directs water into gutter, sheds debris | Can overflow in heavy rain, visible from ground |
| Brush Inserts | Easy DIY install, blocks large debris | Hard to clean, pine needles get stuck |
| Foam Inserts | Inexpensive, DIY-friendly | Can degrade, may promote mold growth |
💡 What We Recommend
-
If your home is surrounded by deciduous trees, mesh guards or surface tension guards that can be removed by hand are your best bet. Make sure these are installed professionally to save time and reduce future problems.
-
If you have pine trees, choose micro-mesh guards specifically rated for fine debris.
-
Even with guards, yearly inspection and cleaning is wise.
-
Always hire professionals to install gutter flashing to prevent water from flowing behind gutters and damaging trim boards and soffit areas (see photo).
Gutter guards can be helpful tools to reduce maintenance—but they’re not magic. The best defense is a combination of the right guard for your tree type and regular, professional cleaning.
Remember: Clean gutters protect your home, just like floss protects your smile.
For professional roofing, gutter guard installation, and gutter cleaning services in the area, trust the experts at Ferreira Exteriors. With decades of experience, we’re here to help protect your home year-round.
